Should I pay off debt or invest?

Pay off debt or invest–that is the question. One of the answers could hinge on whether you’re paying out more debt interest than you're earnings from investments.

Spoiler alert! The answer is going to be both, but we'll dig into whether you might benefit more from paying off debt faster than required or paying the minimum and investing more.

Determining where to focus more of your assets first requires calculating how much money you owe on credit cards, a mortgage, auto and/or student loans, and other outstanding debt and their different interest rates. You'll also need a realistic, conservative estimate of the rate of return on all of your investments. But don’t panic because a Huntington Financial Advisor can assist.

How to balance paying off debt and investing

One rule of thumb (yes, even for this issue) suggests that you consider putting whatever discretionary funds you have toward whatever is higher–the interest rate on your debt, or the expected rate of return of your investments. The bottom line is focusing on what's in your immediate best interest–saving money by paying down debt or earning more through investments.

A conservative benchmark of what your investments could bring in had been 6% based on the average stock market return of 10% per year for the past 100 years†. But market volatility and 40-year high inflation over the last couple years upended that goal. If you get 6% or more, great, but what is really worth thinking about is what's higher, the percentage of interest on debt or percentage of investment returns. A weighted average interest rate is an average that is adjusted to reflect the contribution of each loan to the total debt.

What's your weighted average?

When holding debts with various interest rates, it'll be necessary to figure out the weighted average, which is based on different amounts you owe, and the interest rates assigned to each debt.

No math whiz needed–there's a calculator for that! To figure out the weighted average percentage of interest you're paying on all your debts, you can access this very simple calculator and fill in the fields for balance and interest rate of each debt. You should see the total debt you owe and the weighted average interest rate.

Compare the weighted average interest rate to the estimated rate of return on your investments. Whichever is higher is where you could benefit by placing more of your cash. It may be tempting to focus solely on saving money or paying off debt but it's better to try to handle both. Regardless of where you focus, you should also consider contributing to a 401(k) and/or other retirement funds. This 'pay off debt or invest calculator' can definitely get you started, but a Huntington Financial Advisor could assist with the calculations and investment options as well.

This information may help you determine where more of your focus should be. Because there are many factors to consider when figuring out if you should invest or pay off debt, we can help.

Build your financial know-how

Investment & Retirement

Am I on track to reach my financial goals?

Just asking this question suggests you see the importance of planning for the future. And if you don't yet have a roadmap to reach your financial goals, we can help.

Read More

Investing & Retirement

Basics of Investing in Four Simple Ideas

Investing can be a great part of your financial picture if you understand a few key points.

Read More

Investment & Retirement

What are the benefits of portfolio diversification?

If you concentrate too much money in one asset class, such as stocks, the risk of losing is increased, even when markets are strong. Diversifying your portfolio–investing in a broad combination of stocks, bonds, cash, and other assets–doesn’t guarantee a profit but may help reduce the risk of losses.

Read More

Disclosures

Investment, Insurance and Non-deposit Trust products are: NOT A DEPOSIT • NOT FDIC INSURED • NOT GUARANTEED BY THE BANK • NOT INSURED BY ANY FEDERAL GOVERNMENT AGENCY • MAY LOSE VALUE

Huntington offers a full range of wealth management and financial services through dedicated teams of professionals in the Huntington Private Bank® and Huntington Financial Advisors®, as follows:

  • Banking solutions, including loans and deposit accounts, are provided by The Huntington National Bank, Equal Housing Lender and Member FDIC.
  • Trust and investment management services are provided by The Huntington National Bank, a national bank with fiduciary powers.
  • Certain investment advisory solutions, securities, and insurance products are provided by Huntington Financial Advisors®.
  • Certain insurance products are offered by Huntington Insurance, Inc. and underwritten by third-party insurance carriers not affiliated with Huntington Insurance, Inc.

Huntington Private Bank® is a federally registered service mark of Huntington Bancshares Incorporated.

Huntington Financial Advisors® is a federally registered service mark and a trade name under which The Huntington Investment Company does business as a registered broker-dealer, member FINRA and SIPC, a registered investment advisor with the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC), and a licensed insurance agency.

The Huntington National Bank, The Huntington Investment Company, and Huntington Insurance, Inc., are wholly-owned subsidiaries of Huntington Bancshares Incorporated.

Minimum investment or deposit balance criteria apply with respect to the Huntington Private Bank. Please contact a Huntington Private Bank colleague for more information on eligibility requirements.